Answer: Organic-mat shingles
Explanation: As far as longevity and lifespan your organic shingle is a more modern option. |
| JS SEAMLESS AND ROOFING LLC |
Answer: There is no signifcant difference
Explanation: Standard shingles do there job if installed properly. |
| Condello Construction |
Answer: Fiberglass-mat shingles
Explanation: Determining which asphalt shingle roofing material is definitively "more durable" requires nuanced understanding beyond a simple yes/no answer. Both organic-mat and fiberglass-mat shingles offer advantages and disadvantages depending on your specific needs and priorities. Here's a breakdown to help you choose:
Organic-Mat Shingles:
Pros
Thickness: Offers added insulation and sound dampening.
Flexibility: Conforms better to uneven roof shapes.
Nail-holding power: More resistant to wind uplift.
Adherence to steep slopes: Suitable for roofs with steeper inclines.
Cons
Moisture retention: Prone to absorbing moisture, leading to warping and mildew in humid climates.
Heavier weight: Requires stronger roof structure due to increased weight.
Shorter lifespan: Typically last 15-20 years.
Fire concerns: Less fire-resistant than fiberglass.
Fiberglass-Mat Shingles
Pros
Lightweight: Easier to install and puts less stress on roof structure.
Moisture resistance: Less susceptible to moisture absorption and related problems.
Fire resistance: Inherently fire-resistant due to fiberglass composition.
Longer lifespan: Generally last 20-30 years.
More affordable: Typically cost less than organic-mat shingles.
Cons
Brittleness: Prone to cracking in cold climates.
Lower nail-holding power: Might be less wind-resistant compared to organic-mat.
Less insulation: Offers less soundproofing and thermal insulation.
Not as flexible: Less suitable for complex roof shapes or steep slopes.
Ultimately, the choice depends on your priorities:
Climate: Opt for fiberglass in wet climates, and organic-mat in cold climates with strong winds.
Roof structure: If your roof structure can handle the weight, organic-mat can be beneficial.
Budget: Fiberglass offers a more affordable option.
Appearance: Both materials come in various styles and colors.
Instead of focusing on "more durable," consider "more suitable" for your specific needs. |
| NBS Roofing, Inc. |
|
| ProMatcher |
Answer: Fiberglass-mat shingles
Explanation: LEARN MORE: https://4squareroofing.org |
| 4 Square Roofing |
Answer: Organic-mat shingles
Explanation: Organic-Mat Shingles are more durable due to he fact that they contain more asphalt, these shingles are more rugged and will likely stay put during severe storms. They’re also better suited for homeowners who live in colder climates. This does not mean Fiberglass-Mat shingles are a bad option as they are fire-resistant due to their higher fire rating and recommended in areas prone to wildfires. |
| Top Shield Roofing |
Answer: Fiberglass-mat shingles
Explanation: Fiberglass is far superior to organic |
| JPS-WNC llc |
|
| ProMatcher |
Answer: Fiberglass-mat shingles
Explanation: Fiberglass mat shingle are more forgiving when it comes to shrinking, cupping and destabilization. |
| J. Edmund Construction |
Answer: Fiberglass-mat shingles
Explanation: what I like |
| all-phaze handyman & TV install |
Answer: Fiberglass-mat shingles
Explanation: We prefer Fiberglass-mat shingles because of the interweaving material in them. |
| Moda Roof and Fence Company |
|
| ProMatcher |
Answer: Fiberglass-mat shingles
Explanation: Fiberglass mat shingles are really all we have dealt with. |
| American roofing &remodeling |
Answer: Organic-mat shingles
Explanation: as without fiberglass fibers running thru them they lay flatter as they seal better when the sun beats down on them and they keep sealed down |
| metal masters construction.llc |